Week ending November 18, 2026Tracking the top agents in the top marketsGet the weekly email
Marquee Index

Sold · November 16, 2026

61 N Cartwright Road

New York 11964, Shelter Island, NY

$2,175,000

Rank in New York

#5

of 6 sales in 2026

Price per sq ft

$667

Sale vs. asking

−2.5%

asked $2.23M

A 5-bedroom house in 11964 closed for $2.17 million, about $667 per square foot. The 3,262-square-foot home, built in 1858, spent 39 days on the market and sold 2.5% under its last asking price of $2.23 million.

Type
House
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
4
Interior
3,262 sq ft
Lot
43,560 sq ft
Built
1858
Days on market
39
Last asking
$2,230,000
Closed
November 16, 2026

Context

Other recent sales in 11964

No other recorded sales yet.

The weekly standings

The week's biggest closings and who made them, every Monday.

One email per market. Pick the ones you compete in.